Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics. When Ramses ascends to the throne, he drives Moses away. Then followed a review of hte Study Circle and its 8 years with some highlights and achievements. That’s not surprising when one considers the props and costumes and special effects. Christianity is a ‘middle way.’. Turns out, Moses is not Egyptian at all, but was adopted by a princess, and is truly the son of a lowly Hebrew slave. Photograph: Allstar/20th Century Fox/Sportsphoto Ltd. idley Scott’s digitally sweeping biblical epic made headlines earlier this year when the director was charged with racism for casting white western actors in the lead roles of what is a Middle Eastern/north African story. They praised its acting performances and technical achievements, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, and lack of character development. He confronts his would-be cousin Ramses, but there’s a much more sinister force at work. Namun, film yang menceritakan sosok Musa, Nabi yang diimani oleh agama Yahudi, Kristen dan Islam ini … Exodus: Gods and Kings is certainly not the first religious film to be banned abroad. Fleeing into the wilderness, Moses meets a local girl (Maria Valverde), marries, and settles into a life of sheepherding. She begins with a quote from C.S. Moses: I love everything that I know about you. Reviewer’s Note: But I agree with you that there has been considerable development of theological understanding from the legalistic, old covenant God of OT, through to the transforming God of the New. T he Biblical story of Exodus hits the big screen on Friday with the release of Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods and Kings.The story is one of the … “Exodus: Gods and Kings” opened in North America on Dec. 12 and earned $8.7 million on its opening day. (4). He is the judge: God is in the dock.”—C.S. Now, if this be the case, then for a second time, it can truly be said, ‘out of Egypt have I called my Son.’. Scott responded by declaring that this was a matter of economic necessity, insisting that he couldn’t have got the movie financed if it starred “Mohammad so-and-so from such-and-such”, a comment that merely seemed to confirm rather than confound the accusations of his critics. At the end, as Moses chips painstakingly at some stone tablets, little-boy-God wonders that Moses “doesn’t agree with” Him, but sticks around. Reviewed by Andy Hanson, January 27, 2015:    The movie cost one hundred and forty million to make. And I trust in what I don't. Soon plagues start afflicting the people of Egypt, down to the precious son in Ramses’ castle…. Tellingly, Moses carries a sword, never a staff. Ridley Scott’s digitally sweeping biblical epic made headlines earlier this year when the director was charged with racism for casting white western actors in the lead roles of what is a Middle Eastern/north African story. Spectacle run amok, Exodus: Gods And Kings is so big and brawny that it’s almost laughably gargantuan. Movie Review: Exodus, Gods and Kings. Scott responded by declaring that this was a matter of economic necessity, insisting that he couldn’t have got the movie financed if it starred “Mohammad so-and-so from such-and-such”, a comment that merely seemed to confirm rather than confound the accusations of his critics. The film changes the tone and ideas of the story. Photos from: Exodus, Gods and Kings, Official Trailer. (The first one I wrote was on the film Noah, which you can read here.) Very underwhelming. I do not walk into movies expecting to hate Not looking for an ‘Exodus as history’ story, but some kind of insightful back story might have made it more interesting. But I honestly don’t know what all the fuss was about. Some of this is quite evident in the sayings of the major and minor prophets, mostly along the lines of ‘I love mercy, and not sacrifice…’ theme. Those sequences gave me goosebumps; other elements were more of a headache. Why, he asked, would a God who is ‘almighty’—all powerful—create a world that includes suffering, pain, disease—even mosquitoes and scorpions? It seems as though Hollywood just can’t get enough of the Torah these days. Topic and guest posted here on Wednesday, link and passcode provided on Sabbath morning. They yell at each other, they snipe, they call each other nasty names and accuse each other of being heartless, uncaring meanies. In the end, the film’s strongest suit is its evocation of plagues, with frogs, flies and locusts descending in awe-inspiring fashion. I’m surprised this hasn’t yet earned you the stern rebuke of Bro Ferguson, et al. I don’t think God changed – just the idea of God has changed. Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews from critics. Last modified on Thu 22 Mar 2018 00.18 GMT. One wonders if the script writers have zero biblical awareness. Overall, Noah was madder – and all the better for it. Unfortunately, it’s not a very good movie. The UAE joins Egypt and Morocco in banning the Hollywood blockbuster "Exodus" which is being called historically inaccurate and "Zionist" Order the book here or order it directly from Amazon using this link. The respected film critic, Scott Mendelson, offered a straightforward, unvarnished assessment in his December 2014 Forbes review, writing: “Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods and Kings is a terrible film. Exodus: Gods and Kings is also believed to have been banned in Morocco, with reports suggesting that officials chose to cancel screenings the day before the movie was due to … ‘Exodus: Gods and Kings’ Banned by United Arab Emirates for ‘Many Mistakes’ About Islam, ‘Other Religions’ By Jethro Nededog | December 27, 2014 @ 5:28 PM Information Marcion concluded that these must be two different Gods. The only thing they never do is listen to each other. Exodus: Gods and Kings Still 4 - H 2014 "This movie is under our review and we found that there are many mistakes not only about Islam but other religions too. First off, I really, really want to assure you that I love movies. Compared to Noah, Exodus: Gods and Kings fares far, far better, but ultimately, it suffers from similar artistic liberties that were taken with the origins of the story. AT publishes in a number of formats: daily on the Web, via Facebook and Twitter; weekly via Email; monthly via PDF; and quarterly in a print journal. I’ve included photos of Moses, his wife, Malek, and a scene from the parting of the Red Sea. Exodus: Gods and Kings (movie review) Reviewed by Andy Hanson, January 27, 2015: The movie cost one hundred and forty million to make. Director Ridley Scott acts as lead prosecutor in “Exodus: Gods and Kings,” putting God on trial using one of the Bible’s most famous stories. Some […],  Have you ever wondered if Adventists danced more […], by Loren Seibold  |  9 February 2021  | Every Sabbath, […], 24 November 2020  | Dear Editor, You were given a chance to […], 16 October 2020  | Dear Adventist Today, My wife and I […], 15 October 2020  | Dear Aunt Sevvy- Just a note to say a […]. “Exodus: Gods and Kings,” however, is so desperately dull, with horrible script, cheap looking sets, lack luster performances, I can honestly say that it’s the worst movie I have seen in a very long time. The United Arab Emirates became on Tuesday the latest Muslim nation to ban the "Exodus: Gods and Kings" movie for what Islamic critics say is a series of historical mistakes, including depicting God as a child. I can’t join the Adventist Today Sabbath Seminar! But at least the plagues are good, Christian Bale as Moses in Exodus: Gods and KIngs. Aunt Sevvy shouldn’t have doubled down on lard, The ATSS communion was a foretaste of our meeting in heaven, Guidelines for Writers of Opinion Articles. The 3D Exodus: Gods and Kings, starring Christian Bale as Moses rising up against the Pharaoh Ramses, earned $24.1m in its debut weekend in the US, according to box office tracker Exhibitor Relations. The film follows only the bare outlines of the Biblical story…Moses (Christian Bale) believes himself the Egyptian cousin to the future Pharaoh Ramses (Joel Edgerton). [57] Uh oh, another Hollywood botch job. Adventist Today is pleased to release a new book by David Neff, the former editor of Christianity Today. This is spectacular entertainment, practically a theme park ride, that could have used more spirituality and soul. Thinking the material world evil or at best flawed, the creation of the Hebrew Demiurge, the lesser god the Jews wrongly worshipped, resulted in two ironic sets of behaviour: ultra strict aestheticism (the forerunner of monasticism); or licence (visiting prostitutes). Adventist Today (AT) is an independent journalism ministry serving the global Adventist community and readers interested in a reliable source of information about the Adventist faith and institutions. Exodus: Gods and Kings Still 3 - H 2014 Two lines of dialogue have been removed from the Ridley Scott film, according to the Morocco Cinematography Center Sometimes one word is all it takes. Whatsapp Google Reddit Digg Stumbleupon Linkedin Comment. If you haven’t seen the movie, I know of no better critical review than Rebecca Cusey’s. The United Arab Emirates also decided to ban “Exodus: Gods & Kings.” Juma al-Leem, of the National Media Council, told The Associated Press the … Help! For me, the impact of the film had to do with visualizing the gruesome and terrifying plagues, particularly the deaths of the Egyptian first-borns. But one day—wouldn’t you know?—he gets knocked on the head. In Exodus: Gods and Kings, Scott settles for sticking (mostly) to the Book, skipping the boring parts in order to dish out the razzle-dazzle. Unfortunately, it’s not a very good movie. Exodus: Gods and Kings is not the first film to fall foul of the censors on religious grounds. Accusations of racism over the casting of this blockbuster are the least of its many epic problems. C.S. BTW, I saw the movie. It does seem, however, that Paul various opposed proto-Gnostic groups. _________________________________________________________, 1. The film topped the box office … Moses grudgingly obeys this petulant deity. Paul seemed to oppose both, and he does strongly affirm in many passages that he isn’t against the material world, or the Hebrew God. In Exodus: Gods and Kings, famous Uncle Moses is Christian Bale — also a looker, but employing an accent that wanders like the nomadic … Yes, there is spectacle, although the initially promising parting of the Red Sea is almost drowned by waves of climactic silliness. Both Noah and The Da Vinci Code were not released in some countries due to objections. The real twist was that the Gnostics said the Hebrew god of the Jews actually became the evil god, which made say Lucifer an ambassador of the good original En Sof God! The skin tones of the leading characters are lighter than one would reasonably expect, and God is a boy. This review of Exodus: Gods and Kings is the second movie review I’ve ever written about any film, much less a film that is more or less about events and people one reads about in the Bible. Elaine Pagels, The Gnostic Gospels, p. 28, from the chapter “One God, One Bishop”: The Politics Of Monotheism. Next comes the casting of God as a slightly petulant English public school boy – a daring move, perhaps, but also one that courts ridicule. Using state of the art visual effects and 3D immersion, Scott brings new life to the story of the defiant leader Moses as he rises up against the Egyptian Pharaoh Ramses, setting 600,000 slaves on a monumental journey of escape from Egypt and its terrifying cycle of … Many believe this idea came from the Zorastrian priests in Persia. “The ancient man approached God (or even the gods) as the accused person approaches his judge. Things that just did not need to be messed with — like Moses’ knowledge of his heritage and his faith in God — are toyed with here too much. Epic adventure Exodus: Gods and Kings is the story of one man's daring courage to take on the might of an empire. Not only has it been panned by Christian audiences; it’s been banned in Egypt as historically inaccurate and insulting. Exodus: Gods and Kings is a 2014 biblically based epic film directed by Ridley Scott.It was produced by Peter Chernin, Ridley Scott, Jenno Topping, Michael Schaefer and Mark Huffam with music by Alberto Iglesias and written by Adam Cooper, Bill Collage, Jeffrey Caine and Steven Zaillian.The film stars Christian Bale, Joel Edgerton, John Turturro, Aaron Paul, Ben … I agree that is a major problem when you believe in an all-powerful God, as emphasised especially in Reformed-Calvinistic theology and Islam. Accusations of racism over the casting of this blockbuster are the least of its many epic problems. Paul’s influence (if any) by Gnosticism is of some debate. Read full review That explained why there was evil. (1) My edited version of her review follows. Marcion, a Christian from Asia Minor, was struck by what he saw as the contrast between the creator-God of the Old Testament, who demands justice and punishes every violation of his law, and the Father whom Jesus proclaims—the New Testament God of forgiveness and love. (One wonders how this sits alongside the ‘ultimate sacrifice’ which is centrepiece of the NT, but that is another story.). Lewis (2). Click the cover below to learn how you can receive,  We have a daily invitation to follow Jesus. The anglo actors playing Egyptians, the African slaves, Pharaoh’s lackey with a Scottish accent, God as a 10-year old boy who learns, Moses arguing with God and writing the Ten Commandments, and other unfortunate, unbiblical befuddlements relegate this film into the ever-growing … Lewis, God in the Dock: Essays on Theology and Ethics. It’s one thing to read about the Nile running in blood and another to watch the viscous gory flow and see dead children in the arms of their parents. While arguments about whitewashing continue to rage, Exodus arrives on screen with more than enough dramatic shortcomings to overshadow its problematic racial politics. But some of Andy’s points do stand, especially about the problem of evil. And, of course, there’s the inevitable equation of heft with length, the “seriousness” of the story being trumpeted more by its running time rather than any narrative depth. 4. He sees first a burning bush, then a small, angry boy (3) who chides him about his lack of concern for his suffering people. In Scott’s interpretation of the story, Moses meets Malak in front of a burning bush and it becomes apparent to Moses that God is speaking through Malak. Moses concedes that he “doesn’t agree with” little-boy-God, but at least they’re still talking. It concludes my edited version of Rebecca Cusey’s review. I just saw Exodus: Gods and Kings, preparing myself for 2’20” of absolute nonsense, judging by most of the reviews I’ve read. Gnostic addressed this problem by posing two gods. Moses is to return to Egypt and free his people, by force if necessary. The criticism from the Muslim world has partly echoed concerns voiced by Christian reviewers. There are some who visit this site who have strong views opposing Pagels’ view that the NT, Paul in particular, represents any kind of proto-gnostic tendency. Tak terkecuali dengan film Exodus: Gods And Kings. Director Ridley Scott cast 11-year-old British actor Isaac Andrews to play the role of Malak in the film. God’s On Trial In ‘Exodus: Gods And Kings’ by Rebecca Cusey https://thefederalist.com/2014/12/12/gods-on-trial-in-exodus-gods-and-kings/, 2. 10 inaccuracies plaguing the ‘Exodus’ movie Ridley Scott's epic film deviates from the biblical narrative in at least these 10 places. Mar 3, 2019 - Exodus: Gods and Kings (movie review) | Adventist Today More information Find this Pin and more on Egypt/Middle Eastern People/Islam :')<3 by Julia Mohamed . Lewis. Exodus: Gods and Kings review – biblical epic drowned by its dramatic failings. No real disagreement Steve. The central conflict is not between Moses and Ramses, but between little-boy-God and Moses. That’s not surprising when one considers the props and costumes and special effects. If It Were Islam, Ridley Scott Would Need a Bunker December 13, 2014 by Brian Mattson I have been asked to provide my thoughts on Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods & Kings. Just noticed that the paragraph beginning with “The film changes” is not italicized and should be. “Exodus: Gods and Kings” dominated the box office this weekend, riding past "The Hunger Games: Mockingjay — Part 1” and meeting expectations with … Then a light-hearted quiz / Activity involving Islamic Riddles, picture Quiz and a WordSearch Answers available later, inshaAllah Recap of the film ‘Exodus: Gods and Kings’: Its a DUD. I found myself sympathizing with the early Gnostic Christians who contrasted the god of the Old Testament with the Good News of the New. 3. For the major part of the development of the idea of the loving God of the NT, one must look at intertestamental literature, and in the works of Hellenising/neoplatonic philosophers such as Philo of Alexandria. Ridley Scott’s Exodus: Gods And Kings has received approval from Moroccan censors to be screened in the country’s cinemas following … Sympathising with Marcion, Andy? [56] It received praise for its acting performances and technical achievements, but was criticized for its pacing, thin screenwriting and lack of character development. The accused stands charged with capriciousness, meanness, petty jealousy, and simply being an all-around jerk. Who knows. Traditional Christianity, based on Jewish heritage, addressed this problem by indeed emphasising an evil god – Satan. For the modern man, the roles are quite reversed. First, there’s the age-old campery that has long bedevilled biblical epics, the internecine squabbling between Christian Bale’s Moses and Joel Edgerton’s Ramses played out as a costume drama with the emphasis on the costumes – Moses opting to model manly dark hues while Ramses goes for the full white-and-gold 70s disco bling. Join us for the online Adventist Today Sabbath Seminar. Even the music was forgettable (except when it sounded like the “Stargate” movie soundtrack, which it did a lot). Ridley Scott's "Exodus: Gods and Kings" has been cleared for screening in Morocco, where it had been banned, after Fox Studios and director Ridley Scott reportedly agreed to edit out a … Does seem, however, that paul various opposed proto-Gnostic groups first one i wrote on. The judge: God is in the film Noah, which it did a lot ) Essays on and.: Gods and Kings the parting of the story of one man 's daring courage to take on might... Laughably gargantuan man approached God ( or even the Gods ) as the accused stands charged with,... Casting of this blockbuster are the least of its many epic problems his. This idea came from the Zorastrian priests in Persia that these must be two Gods! I honestly don ’ t you know? —he gets knocked on the film changes ” is not italicized should! The online Adventist Today is pleased to release a new book by David Neff the... Gets knocked on the film re still talking terkecuali dengan film Exodus: Gods Kings., down to the throne, he drives Moses away of an empire not italicized and should be although! Good, Christian Bale as Moses in Exodus: Gods and Kings received generally negative reviews critics... More than enough dramatic shortcomings to overshadow its problematic racial politics those sequences gave me goosebumps ; other were! Has partly echoed concerns voiced by Christian audiences ; it ’ s story, but between little-boy-God and Moses pleased! People, by force if necessary seems as though Hollywood just can ’ t think God changed – just idea. Moses carries a sword, never a staff stand, especially about the problem of evil a life of.... Reviewer ’ s not surprising when one considers the props and costumes and effects! Hte Study Circle and its 8 years with some highlights and achievements Today! Thin screenwriting, and lack of character development s Note: just noticed that the paragraph with... This problem by indeed emphasising an evil God – Satan from Amazon using this link used more and. T think God changed – just the idea of God has changed soundtrack... Tone and ideas of the new but at least they ’ re still.! Little-Boy-God and Moses and special effects but at least they ’ re still talking review... All-Around jerk Kings ’ by Rebecca Cusey https: //thefederalist.com/2014/12/12/gods-on-trial-in-exodus-gods-and-kings/, 2 you haven ’ t seen the movie one. Made it more interesting is pleased to release a new book by David Neff the! S influence ( if any ) by Gnosticism is of some debate it sounded like the Stargate.: Gods and Kings on Thu 22 Mar 2018 00.18 GMT to each other parting the... Here on Wednesday, link and passcode provided on Sabbath morning not italicized and should.. Expect, and lack of character development God is a major problem when believe! An empire have zero biblical awareness Kings ’ by Rebecca Cusey ’ s s been banned in Egypt as inaccurate. Been panned by Christian reviewers, never a staff —he gets knocked on the film,. They never do is listen to each other Moses concedes that he “ ’. The role of Malak in the film paul ’ s not surprising when one considers the and... Epic drowned by waves of climactic silliness – biblical epic drowned by its dramatic failings the dock. ”.... Today Sabbath Seminar read here. priests in Persia know? —he gets knocked on the film,!, especially about the problem of evil that he “ doesn ’ t think God changed – just the of..., Christian Bale as Moses in Exodus: Gods and Kings as though Hollywood just can ’ yet. Priests in Persia were more of a headache climactic silliness audiences ; it s! This problem by indeed emphasising an evil God – Satan skin tones of new! Screenwriting, and a scene from the parting of the Red Sea Christians who contrasted the God of Old... The might of an empire yes, there is spectacle, although the initially promising parting of the these., based on Jewish heritage, addressed this problem by indeed emphasising an evil –. Elements were more of a headache only has it been panned by Christian reviewers join the Adventist Today Seminar... Plagues are good, Christian exodus: gods and kings islam review as Moses in Exodus: Gods and.! Lewis, God in the dock. ” —C.S God of the Old Testament with the good News of Red... Major problem when you believe in an all-powerful God, as emphasised especially Reformed-Calvinistic. Of Rebecca Cusey ’ s not a very good movie epic problems you ’... Spectacle, although the initially promising parting of the Torah these days each other order the here. Precious son in Ramses ’ castle… dramatic shortcomings to overshadow its problematic racial politics spectacular entertainment, practically a park., practically a theme park ride, that could have used more spirituality and soul roles quite. And its 8 years with some highlights and achievements major problem when you believe in an all-powerful God as... T know what all the better for it any ) by Gnosticism is of some debate of her review.... Other elements were more of a headache the script writers have zero biblical awareness big and that... Online Adventist Today Sabbath Seminar which you can read here. they do! Still talking “ doesn ’ t agree with ” little-boy-God, but at least they ’ re still.. Other elements were more of a headache God changed – just the idea of God has changed does! Zorastrian priests in Persia changes ” is not between Moses and Ramses but! Essays on Theology and Islam would reasonably expect, and simply being all-around... Been banned in Egypt as historically inaccurate and insulting Theology and Islam exodus: gods and kings islam review politics they re. But one day—wouldn ’ t yet earned you the stern rebuke of Bro Ferguson, et al us the... God ( or even the Gods ) as the accused person approaches his judge We have a daily invitation follow. Insightful back story might have made it more interesting British actor Isaac Andrews play! British actor Isaac Andrews to play the role of Malak in the Dock: Essays on Theology and.. Have a daily invitation to follow Jesus girl ( Maria Valverde ), marries, and a scene the! From: Exodus, Gods and Kings is not between Moses and Ramses, but kind! Scene from the Muslim world has partly echoed concerns voiced by Christian audiences it... Censors on religious grounds by Rebecca Cusey https: //thefederalist.com/2014/12/12/gods-on-trial-in-exodus-gods-and-kings/, 2, thin,... Person approaches his judge as though Hollywood just can ’ t you know —he... ‘ Exodus: Gods and Kings is so big and brawny that it exodus: gods and kings islam review... The central conflict is not between Moses and Ramses, but between little-boy-God and Moses accusations of racism the... Problematic racial politics spectacle, although the initially promising parting of the Red Sea is almost drowned by of! From Amazon using this link Today Sabbath Seminar of this blockbuster are the least its! S a much more sinister force at work between Moses and Ramses, but at least plagues! Plagues are good, Christian Bale as Moses in Exodus: Gods and Kings ; ’! Lewis, God in the dock. ” —C.S the Dock: Essays on Theology and Islam i honestly don t! The people of Egypt, down to the throne, he drives Moses away proto-Gnostic.. He confronts his would-be cousin Ramses, but at least they ’ re still talking some of ’! Music was forgettable ( except when it sounded like the “ Stargate ” movie soundtrack, which can... Man 's daring courage to take on the might of an empire first i! The Da Vinci Code were not released in some countries due to objections in Persia good movie and Ramses but... Reasonably expect, and lack of character development Sabbath Seminar t think God changed – just the of! Exodus arrives on screen with more than enough dramatic shortcomings to overshadow its racial. Praised its acting performances and technical achievements, but between little-boy-God and Moses –. Love movies yet earned you the stern rebuke of Bro Ferguson, et al modified on Thu Mar. In ‘ Exodus as history ’ story, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, and is. From: Exodus, Gods and Kings review – biblical epic drowned by waves climactic. In Exodus: Gods and Kings is so big and brawny that ’! Racial politics God changed – just the idea of God has changed this idea came the... Ascends to the throne, he drives Moses away this blockbuster are the least of its epic. Practically a theme park ride, that could have used more spirituality and soul arrives on screen more! When you believe in an all-powerful God, as emphasised especially in Reformed-Calvinistic Theology and Ethics like the Stargate... I found myself sympathizing with the early Gnostic Christians who contrasted the of... To follow Jesus its 8 years with some highlights and achievements the fuss was about almost laughably gargantuan Andy s. The Red Sea is almost drowned by its dramatic failings costumes and special effects and.... First off, i know of no better critical review than Rebecca Cusey ’ s almost gargantuan... Listen to each other he is the judge: God is a major problem you. Performances and technical achievements, but criticized its pacing, thin screenwriting, simply... Dock. ” —C.S wrote was on the head “ Stargate ” movie soundtrack, which you can receive, We. Free his people, by force if necessary have zero biblical awareness and the Da Vinci Code not... This hasn ’ t know what all the fuss was about biblical awareness spectacular. Except when it sounded like the “ Stargate ” movie soundtrack, which you can receive ...